The long-awaited sequel, The Devil Wears Prada 2, arrives two decades after the original, bringing back iconic characters but facing significant challenges. While the film initially piques interest with its engaging premise, it ultimately struggles with deeper narrative shortcomings.
In the summer of 2006, the original film was a delightful surprise, blending sharp humor with outstanding performances and memorable fashion moments. Anticipation for the sequel was high, yet skepticism lingered regarding the pitfalls often associated with follow-ups—overcomplicated plots, excessive celebrity appearances, and blatant product placements.
The sequel opens with Andy Sachs, portrayed by Anne Hathaway, receiving an award for her investigative journalism, only to discover that her newspaper has collapsed, leaving her and her colleagues jobless. Coincidentally, Runway magazine faces a crisis due to a scandal involving a fashion label accused of using sweatshop labor. To rehabilitate the magazine’s tarnished reputation, the higher-ups appoint Miranda Priestly’s former assistant as the new features editor—a decision that surprises Miranda, played by Meryl Streep, who does not even recall meeting Andy.
This narrative acknowledges the seismic shifts in media over the past two decades, particularly in fashion journalism, which has evolved significantly with the advent of social media platforms like Instagram and YouTube. The film introduces Miranda as a target of online criticism post-scandal, while also showcasing her concern for her articles’ viewership. However, the plot soon becomes entangled in a power struggle following the unexpected death of Runway’s aging owner, resulting in budget cuts that humiliate Miranda, forcing her to fly commercial to Milan.
The film introduces new supporting characters, but they lack depth, and the actors—including Kenneth Branagh, Lucy Liu, and Justin Theroux—fail to bring their roles to life. Although Miranda acknowledges her past mistreatment of her loyal fashion director, Nigel, portrayed by Stanley Tucci, her attempts at redemption hardly compensate for her previous behavior. Given Nigel’s solitary existence, one would hope she could at least assist him in finding companionship.
Furthermore, the character of Emily Charlton, played by Emily Blunt, receives forgiveness despite her actions in her new role at Dior, raising questions about merit and accountability. The underlying issue remains the toxic culture at Runway, which the original film vividly portrayed. While Andy strives to create a healthier work environment for her assistant, the film glosses over the challenges involved in changing a workplace culture. It would have been more impactful for Andy to prioritize improving conditions at Runway, especially after saving the magazine and Miranda’s position. The absence of a commitment from Miranda to treat her staff with greater respect, or a moment for Emily to express the lasting scars of working under Miranda, diminishes the film’s potential for growth and resolution.
Andy’s vibrant spirit provides a refreshing contrast to the aloofness of those around her, with Hathaway delivering a performance full of enthusiasm. The sequel maintains a brisk pace, and the return of familiar characters generates nostalgia. The script is clever enough to avoid making viewers feel guilty for enjoying the lavish setting, unlike other sequels that miss the mark. However, it is disappointing that The Devil Wears Prada 2 opts for an overly optimistic view that seems beneath its characters’ maturity.
The Devil Wears Prada 2 features Anne Hathaway and Meryl Streep, directed by David Frankel and written by Aline Brosh McKenna. The film is rated PG-13.
