The recent elections have concluded, but the efforts to hold Texas officials accountable are just beginning. The Texas Supreme Court announced on Friday that it will not entertain a challenge to a comprehensive law designed to prevent cities and counties from implementing policies that regulate payday lending, water breaks for construction workers, and other local ordinances that may conflict with state regulations.
In response, Democrats are gearing up to repeal this statute when the Texas Legislature reconvenes in January.
Controversy Surrounding the Law
Critics have labeled the legislation the “Death Star bill,” arguing that it prohibits local governments from enacting regulations that exceed those permitted by overarching state laws. This has raised concerns among advocates who view it as a measure by Republican lawmakers aimed at stifling progressive policies at the municipal level.
A coalition of cities, including Houston, San Antonio, and El Paso, had sought to overturn a lower court’s decision that upheld the law’s constitutionality. However, the ruling of that lower court will remain in effect for the time being.
Enacted in 2023, the law was championed by Governor Greg Abbott, Republican legislators, and business advocacy groups, who contended that it was essential to prevent municipalities from instituting regulations detrimental to business owners and the state’s economic growth.
Consequently, various local ordinances, such as those regulating noise levels and vehicle towing, have been rescinded. Local officials have raised alarms that the law’s expansive nature creates confusion over which regulations may now be deemed illegal, hindering their ability to pursue policies due to fears of potential lawsuits.
Legal Developments
A judge in Travis County ruled the law unconstitutional in August 2023 but permitted it to take effect. Subsequently, the cities of Houston, San Antonio, and El Paso filed a lawsuit against the state, claiming the law contravenes a provision of the Texas Constitution that grants municipalities the authority to establish their own regulations.
However, the 3rd Court of Appeals reversed the lower court’s decision, concluding that the cities had failed to demonstrate how the law would inflict harm upon them or establish the state’s liability.
With Democrats now holding leadership positions in the Texas House and statewide offices, there is a concerted effort to repeal the Death Star bill in the upcoming legislative session. Governor-elect Gina Hinojosa has expressed her intent to see the law abolished, and State Senator José Menéndez, a Democrat from San Antonio, has introduced a bill aimed at this goal. Nevertheless, this initiative is likely to encounter significant opposition in the Texas Senate, where Republicans maintain a majority.
