The election may have concluded, but the effort to hold Texas officials accountable is just beginning. Outgoing Comptroller Don Huffines has proposed significant tax cuts on cloud computing, artificial intelligence, internet hosting, and data storage, a move that could potentially cost the state $18 billion in revenue over the next six years, according to his office’s estimates.
Huffines, a Republican who recently lost his re-election bid, announced an administrative change aimed at redefining taxable data processing services. He argued that previous interpretations were overly broad and not reflective of the current technological landscape.
The tax on data processing was established by the Legislature in 1987, and Huffines contended that the original wording does not adequately cover today’s advancements. He maintained that the law should only apply to traditional services like word processing, data entry, data retrieval, and payroll and business accounting data production.
“Bureaucrats have unlawfully stretched a 40-year-old statute to include every new technology that emerged, and Texas businesses and families have borne the cost,” he stated. “Those practices are now behind us.”
If the tax cuts proceed, they are expected to greatly affect state and local budgets in the coming years. Jeffrey Clemmons, speaking on behalf of Democratic Comptroller-elect Sarah Eckhardt, indicated that the actions taken by Huffines during the interim period between Election Day and Eckhardt’s inauguration on January 1 would be thoroughly examined. Eckhardt’s transition team had previously requested that Huffines halt all new rulemaking for the duration of his term.
According to projections from Huffines’ office, the state could face a loss of $1.9 billion in general revenue and nearly $600 million in local sales tax revenue by fiscal year 2027. By fiscal year 2032, these losses could escalate to $4.3 billion for the state and approximately $1.1 billion for local governments.
Overall, the anticipated impact on state sales tax collections could result in an $18 billion shortfall over the next six years, with local governments facing a total loss of $4.67 billion during that period. Texas generates over $250 billion in revenue annually, making this potential loss significant. For context, the state’s school voucher program is expected to cost $1 billion in the 2026-27 biennium, and efforts to expand the border wall between 2021 and 2025 amounted to $3 billion.
Local governments, including cities, counties, and transit authorities, have the authority to implement local sales taxes of up to 2% on top of the state’s base rate of 6.25%. These funds are crucial for financing essential services such as road maintenance, emergency services, and public safety initiatives.
Huffines has claimed that the tax is already being contested through legal challenges and administrative reviews, which could expose Texas to financial risks greater than the losses anticipated from eliminating the tax.
Under the newly proposed regulations, as outlined in the Texas Register, the definition of a data processing service would be restricted to scenarios where a provider processes customer-supplied information and returns it in an organized, usable format. New categories would exempt internet services, AI, applications, and cloud computing from taxation, classified instead as “hosted technology services.” Additionally, the proposal would permit multistate allocation of software sales, allowing Texas to tax only the portion of the sale applicable within the state.
“Texans should not incur taxes merely for storing personal photos and documents in the cloud, nor should small businesses face taxes for website hosting—such levies ultimately burden consumers with higher prices,” Huffines emphasized in his statement.
The proposed regulatory changes are set for publication in the Texas Register on Friday, initiating a 30-day period for public comment. State agencies are required to consider public input on proposed rules before finalizing them, with the earliest adoption date potentially falling on December 20, just 12 days after Eckhardt takes office.
This initiative forms part of Huffines’ Taxpayer First Project, launched in August, which seeks to limit or eliminate various taxes, including those on medical records and streaming services. Additionally, Huffines has urged state contractors to utilize a federal database to confirm the compliance of their employees with U.S. immigration laws.
The proposed changes to the tax policy have sparked tensions between Huffines and Eckhardt, who is preparing to take over the office. In a letter dated November 9, Eckhardt requested that Huffines halt any rule changes initiated after August 1, arguing that these actions disrupt the transition process.
In a response issued on Monday, Huffines rejected Eckhardt’s request, asserting that it would undermine the Taxpayer First Project. He accused her of demonstrating “emotional contempt for the Texas Constitution and Texas taxpayers” in her correspondence.
