Nearly ten years ago, a British court mandated that Sam Westrop pay over $173,000 in libel damages after he published an article on his website labeling the founder of a London-based Islamic TV channel as a “convicted terrorist.”
Subsequently, Westrop acknowledged that the evidence supporting his claim was unreliable, as indicated in court documents, and rectified the article on his site. The presiding judge remarked, “There simply was no evidence to support the allegation of terrorism.”
Years after the ruling, Westrop voiced similar accusations regarding a group of Islamic private schools in Texas that had applied for the state’s new voucher program. He alleged that the school leaders had links to extremist groups, including Hamas. His findings were shared with the Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts, which oversees the voucher program that allocates taxpayer funds for private education or homeschooling, as early as last fall.
In December, acting Comptroller Kelly Hancock sought guidance from the state’s top lawyer on whether schools with purported ties to the Chinese Communist government or those that had hosted events for the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR), a Muslim civil rights organization, could be excluded from the voucher program. A month later, Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton ruled in favor of this exclusion.
Westrop’s assertions, along with similar claims from others, were among the key factors prompting the comptroller’s office to investigate the schools and postpone their entry into the voucher program, as revealed in new legal filings.
The investigations turned out to be broader than initially reported, with the state using taxpayer funds to hire two investigators to examine the histories of nearly 50 private schools statewide that were allegedly linked to radical Islamic organizations and the Chinese government.
This extensive inquiry and Westrop’s role have come to light in a recent set of legal documents filed in a lawsuit by four Islamic private school campuses against the state comptroller. This action was initiated in March after the agency initially barred their participation in the voucher program. The filings significantly reference an eight-hour deposition of Murl Miller, the comptroller’s chief counsel for general litigation, conducted in May as part of the lawsuit.
Although the comptroller has since accepted all investigated schools into the voucher program, the schools involved in the legal action are still urging the judge to approve a class-action lawsuit to prevent future discrimination against certain private schools.
“Religious liberty is not a temporary pass issued after a lawsuit,” stated Eric Hudson, the attorney representing the Islamic schools. “We’re pressing on so equal treatment is the rule — not an exception granted under pressure.”
The comptroller’s office, which declined to comment on the matter, has opposed the certification of the lawsuit as a class action, arguing that it should not proceed since the four Islamic campuses were eventually admitted into the voucher program. The state’s legal team asserts that the class-action claim falls outside the jurisdiction of the current court and case.
“Plaintiffs received not only the initial approval they sought, but also the continuing ability to participate in the Program on the same footing as all other approved providers and families,” the state’s filing from June 26 stated.
The controversy surrounding the inclusion of these schools in the voucher program has unfolded against a backdrop of rising anti-Muslim sentiments among certain elected officials and high-profile political candidates in Texas and nationwide. At the recent state Republican Party convention, there were attempts to exclude Muslims from serving as delegates. Dr. Rick Scarborough, a former Southern Baptist pastor, confronted a Muslim attendee, insisting he should leave the event. Scarborough later clarified that he meant the attendee should leave the country, expressing some regret over the incident. Additionally, in November, Texas Governor Greg Abbott designated CAIR as a foreign terrorist organization, a claim soon echoed by Florida’s governor. CAIR is currently involved in a lawsuit against Abbott and Paxton, challenging the governor’s designation on the grounds of lacking due process and violating federal law.
Since the Islamic schools filed their lawsuit, the comptroller’s office has asserted that its leaders did not intentionally target specific schools. Instead, officials asserted that the Islamic schools were included in a broader review of approximately 700 private schools accredited by Cognia, a nonprofit organization that evaluates thousands of schools globally. The agency claimed it was unaware of which schools had Islamic affiliations until it discovered that not all schools had up-to-date accreditations, which are required to qualify for the Texas voucher program. Cognia could not be reached for immediate comment.
However, Miller’s deposition contradicts the state’s narrative. He stated that the agency had received information identifying nearly 50 schools with alleged connections to the Chinese Communist Party or extremist groups as early as the previous summer. Miller confirmed that the third-party researchers hired by the comptroller focused solely on those specific campuses, which is a fraction of the over 2,600 private schools currently approved for the voucher program.
The filing also revealed that the comptroller initially approved at least one of the Islamic schools involved in the lawsuit, Bayaan Academy, before revoking its approval shortly after Westrop shared his research in January via email.
Miller’s deposition cited various sources that prompted the comptroller’s investigations into the schools, including input from Westrop, a regional Homeland Security Task Force established to combat emerging threats from transnational criminal organizations in Southeast Texas, congressional hearings investigating potential terrorist activities in Texas, and the RAIR Foundation, an organization focused on countering perceived threats from radical groups.
Miller confirmed that he had a phone conversation with Westrop earlier this year, during which he found Westrop to be credible. When questioned about whether he had researched Westrop’s background, Miller admitted he had not. He added that the investigators hired by the state had verified Westrop’s credentials.
When asked if they had informed him of a defamation ruling against Westrop for falsely labeling someone a terrorist, Miller responded negatively.
Westrop, who could not be reached for comment, was recently employed by the Texas Public Policy Foundation, a prominent conservative think tank based in Austin. He has continued to raise concerns on at least one podcast about extremist groups potentially exploiting the school voucher program funding.
He later published his research, which he had previously shared with the comptroller, on the Middle East Forum, a platform established in 1994 that advocates for American interests in the Middle East and aims to protect the West from perceived threats.
During his deposition, Miller indicated that the comptroller’s office was “not readily prepared to conduct investigations and deep research into foreign terrorist organizations or any other accusations.” Instead, the comptroller relied on Westrop’s list of accused schools and handed it over to two third-party counterterrorism researchers, Reuben Katz and Lara Burns, a retired FBI agent affiliated with George Washington University’s Program on Extremism.
Katz and Burns provided the agency with detailed dossiers on each school, cross-referencing school leaders against government databases of terrorism and extremist groups.
Ultimately, the comptroller permitted all schools alleged to have ties to Islamic terrorism or the Chinese Communist Party to enter the program.
The plaintiffs from the Islamic schools have expressed concerns that their inclusion in the program is not guaranteed in the long run and are advocating for a class-action suit to reform the comptroller’s processes that led to their initial exclusion.
The filing referenced a letter dated March 24 from Hancock to the state attorney general, wherein he reiterated claims connecting the principal of the Houston Quran Academy to the Muslim Brotherhood. In the letter, he indicated that the school had been “temporarily” accepted into the voucher program but called for its removal. The school’s principal, Hamed Ghazali, has stated that they have no affiliations with CAIR and focus solely on academic endeavors. Hancock also urged the attorney general to revoke the school’s corporate charter, citing what he alleged were ties to terrorism. Hancock has since announced his resignation from the position of acting comptroller at the end of this month.
Miller acknowledged in his deposition that Hancock’s letter contained “numerous mistakes and misstatements,” yet noted, “I’m not the acting comptroller.” He asserted that the accusations of terrorist connections were not substantiated, adding, “This letter came completely out of the blue, and — and so this was a surprise to all of us.”
When asked if the comptroller had the authority to remove a school from the approved list, overriding the agency’s internal research, Miller initially resisted the notion but eventually conceded. “It’s possible, yes,” he affirmed.
