Sign up for The Brief, a daily newsletter that keeps readers informed about the most important news in Texas.
Recent updates to Texas’ private school voucher program have clarified that families wishing to enroll their children in private pre-K can receive approximately $10,800 annually, which is the same amount allocated for most other participants in the program.
However, this financial support is not expected to significantly change the landscape of early childhood education in Texas, as only students already eligible for free public pre-K will qualify for these private pre-K services.
The legislation that established this program earlier this year allows nearly any school-age child to apply for an education savings account, which is a form of vouchers enabling families to use public funds to support their children’s private or home-school education. Additionally, a lesser-known aspect of the law permits certain families to utilize state funding to send their children to accredited private pre-K providers, provided they are not also enrolled in a public program.
This incentive is limited to 3- and 4-year-olds who meet at least one of several criteria for receiving free public pre-K, such as being an English learner, coming from a low-income household, or having a parent who is active in the military or works as a public school teacher.
While introducing another pre-K option may assist families who navigate the voucher application process successfully and find a participating private provider, experts caution against viewing it as a comprehensive solution to the access and affordability issues currently affecting early education in Texas. Catherine Davis, the policy director for Fort Worth-based Child Care Associates, which advocated for the inclusion of private pre-K in the program, remarked, “I think, generally, this is not going to be the game changer for pre-K.”
Research indicates that high-quality pre-K programs contribute to favorable academic and social-emotional outcomes for students. However, advocates highlight that systemic barriers hinder access to these benefits for all Texans.
While Texas mandates that public schools provide a full day of pre-K for eligible families, it only finances half-day programs. Consequently, school districts often face difficult decisions about whether to allocate limited resources towards pre-K or other pressing needs. Recent changes to the state’s early education funding distribution may help some districts fully fund preschool programs.
Currently, around 250,000 students are enrolled in public pre-K programs in Texas, while an additional 282,000 eligible children are not participating. This discrepancy suggests that some families might be unaware that free public pre-K is available to them.
Families who do not meet the stringent criteria for public pre-K must seek alternatives. Unfortunately, the private sector can be an impractical solution for those struggling financially. The average cost of private preschool in Texas is approximately $13,521 per year, as reported by Private School Review. Additionally, preschools may have waitlists, and financial aid options, such as scholarships for alternative child care solutions, can also be limited.
While the introduction of school vouchers presents additional pre-K options for some families, the implications of this investment remain uncertain, particularly due to the strict eligibility requirements.
The $1 billion program is set to accept about 100,000 students from a larger pool of more than 5.5 million children enrolled in Texas’ K-12 public schools, as well as 560,000 who are home-schooled and 350,000 attending private schools.
“The question that I think remains is whether families will opt out of using public pre-K when vouchers are an option,” stated Erin Baumgartner, director of the Houston Education Research Consortium at Rice University.
The effectiveness of private pre-K under the voucher program will also hinge on public awareness. A recent survey conducted by Texas Southern University, involving 900 families with children in pre-K through 12th grade, revealed that 53% were either unfamiliar or had limited knowledge of the program.
Several agencies oversee Texas’ child care system, each with distinct rules and eligibility standards, which can lead to confusion for families seeking accurate information. This issue is particularly pronounced in programs aimed at low-income families, who are eligible for state funding for private pre-K.
Looking at existing voucher programs in other states, it is likely that participation in Texas’ program will be skewed towards more affluent and predominantly white families whose children already attend private schools.
“All that data is going to be really interesting to follow over the first couple of years to really see how this shakes out and who’s really using” education savings accounts, remarked Kim Kofron, director of early childhood education for the nonprofit Children at Risk. “That’s really going to be, to me, really, where the story is: What do parents really want?”
CJ Walia, a private pre-K provider in North Texas, noted that the state funding of over $10,000 would cover around 70% of his school’s fees, meaning families would need to pay the remaining balance out of pocket.
Walia intends to inform his school community about the voucher program but doubts many will qualify due to income restrictions.
Parents seeking guidance on child care options might benefit from improved collaboration between public and private providers, who sometimes view each other as competitors rather than partners. Wendy Uptain, executive director of Early Matters Texas, a child care advocacy organization, emphasized, “No single group — public schools, child care providers, or policymakers — is going to solve this one on their own. The communities that are making the most progress are where those partners are working together.”
