Monica Barbaro shines brightly in “One Night Only,” a film that showcases her talents far better than her previous acclaimed role in “A Complete Unknown.” In this romantic comedy set in a reimagined New York City, Barbaro plays Allie, a working musician who sings, dances, and plays the piano, all while dressed in a stylish high-hemmed dress that accentuates her long legs. The film’s premise revolves around a society where single individuals are surveilled and prohibited from engaging in intimate relationships except for one designated night each year. This intriguing backdrop raises questions about personal freedom and societal constraints.
In this near-future America, the narrative unfolds during the annual night of permissible intimacy. Allie, yearning for love in a city rife with sexual encounters, finds herself in a Chinese restaurant, sulking over a soup dumpling while observing couples around her. The film takes a satirical look at the absurdities of this dystopian setup, which draws parallels to current societal issues but misses a chance to delve deeper into its implications. The script, penned by Travis Braun, lacks the sharpness needed to connect these themes effectively.
The story follows Allie and Owen (played by Callum Turner), a pizza shop manager who faces an unexpected breakup just hours before the night of freedom. Their paths cross repeatedly as they both navigate a series of comedic misadventures while attempting to engage with others. Director Will Gluck captures the film’s snappy tone and farcical elements, allowing for moments of humor amidst the chaos.
Turner brings a relatable charm to his role, creating a chemistry with Barbaro that prevents the film from feeling like a one-woman showcase. In supporting roles, non-binary pop singer King Princess impresses as Allie’s best friend, while Maya Hawke portrays Owen’s ex-girlfriend. Bobby Cannavale and Pete Davidson add comedic flair as actors whose shooting schedule is hilariously interrupted by Owen’s escapades.
What elevates “One Night Only” is Barbaro’s performance, which echoes the brilliance of Emma Stone in “Easy A.” Her portrayal of a disenchanted yet hopeful Allie, who finds herself tangled in a comical dating scene while also juggling her job as a jingle singer, resonates with viewers. Despite the film’s outlandish premise, Barbaro’s talent shines through, leaving audiences wishing for more substantial romantic comedies that could fully utilize her abilities.
As the credits roll on “One Night Only,” viewers are left with a sense of longing—not just for a better film premise, but for a future where a talent like Barbaro finds herself in a more fitting project, be it a rom-com or a musical. Her capabilities deserve to be showcased in a more meaningful and engaging manner.
One Night Only
Starring Monica Barbaro and Callum Turner. Directed by Will Gluck. Written by Travis Braun. Rated R.
