Texas Faces Multi-Million Dollar Bill to Correct Bluebonnet School Materials Errors, Contract Reveals

Texas Faces Multi Million Dollar Bill to Correct Bluebonnet School Materials Errors, Contract Reveals

The Texas Education Agency is set to allocate up to $8.4 million in taxpayer funds to rectify thousands of errors found in learning materials that have attracted national attention due to their inclusion of Bible stories.

This funding will cover the costs associated with printing and shipping new materials, as well as the disposal of the current set, as outlined in a contract shared by Pam Little, a Republican member of the State Board of Education. Texans will bear the financial burden of approximately 4,200 corrections to the Bluebonnet Learning program, which was developed using state resources.

The required corrections address a range of issues, including hundreds of copyright infringements, formatting mistakes, and typographical errors. Educators have previously voiced concerns about additional problems, such as missing pages, incorrect answer keys, and the physical deterioration of the materials.

One teacher noted last year, “The slide deck for the handwriting portion is out of order for the workbook page.” Another administrator pointed out, “The story of Carlo and Leonardo is missing. Teacher Resources page 357 lists it, and it is referred to in Unit 2 Lesson 3. The actual story is missing.” A separate administrator added, “Pages are coming loose and flying around the classroom.”

The State Board of Education approved the Bluebonnet materials for public school use starting in 2024. Board members have been aware of the errors since January, but the financial implications of correcting these issues have only recently become clear.

The $8.4 million expense, first highlighted by FOX4 Dallas-Fort Worth, arises at a time when state leaders have been critical of school districts, attributing a funding crisis to mismanagement and excessive spending.

See also  Trump Grants Pardon to Election Official Tina Peters Amid State Court Charges

Little expressed her intention to inquire about the costs with Texas Education Commissioner Mike Morath following his quarterly briefing to the board this week. Unfortunately, scheduling conflicts and a delayed start to the meeting prevented that discussion, according to education agency spokesperson Jake Kobersky.

Kobersky remarked, “The errors are unacceptable, and the vendor responsible for them has been terminated. The TEA has also revised its contracting procedures to ensure that any future errors will result in costs incurred by the vendor.”

The total cost translates to just under $5 per student across the affected schools, Kobersky noted.

Board members remarked that the scale of the 4,200 corrections is highly unusual. For context, four other publishers that submitted correction requests around the same time reported a combined total of just 16 edits.

Little elaborated earlier this year, “The fact that they have requested licensing changes and the presence of these items leaves us vulnerable to lawsuits for copyright violations.”

Bluebonnet, a program for elementary and secondary school reading and math, is often promoted by state leaders as a high-quality educational resource, offering a $60 incentive per student for districts that implement it. Nearly 600 districts were set to utilize some of its materials as of last year.

Criticism has arisen regarding the K-5 reading segment for its use of Bible stories, while others have raised concerns about the curriculum’s treatment of issues such as racism and slavery.

Simultaneously, the State Board of Education is scheduled to vote on Friday regarding a major revision of Texas’ social studies curriculum and a mandatory reading list, both of which have faced scrutiny for their emphasis on Christianity and insufficient focus on racial, gender, and cultural diversity.

See also  East Texas Republicans Break the Mold: A Unique Approach to Campaigning Beyond Culture War Rhetoric