FORT STOCKTON — Ruben Falcon, a former mayor in this oil-centric town, reflects on the few elected officials he holds in high regard. Having been instrumental in rallying support for various politicians, the West Texas Republican has developed a keen ability to discern those who truly care about the vast, predominantly rural region.
Falcon believes Congressman Tony Gonzales is among those who understand the unique challenges of small-town life. “I feel like Congressman Gonzales, being from a small town himself, comprehends how difficult it is to access necessary resources and to convey the message that ‘you matter too,’” he stated.
However, the list of supporters for Gonzales seems to dwindle daily. The San Antonio Republican has faced serious allegations, including an affair with his staff member, Regina Santos-Aviles, who tragically died in September 2025. Following her death, Gonzales has resisted calls for his resignation, even as her husband recently publicized illicit text messages exchanged between the two.
Local political leaders from various backgrounds in West Texas express a consensus: Gonzales’s chances of retaining his precarious seat in Congressional District 23, which stretches from San Antonio to El Paso, appear grim. Observers note that the scandals overshadow his previous accomplishments and highlight a growing disconnect between him and the constituents he is meant to represent.
In contrast, numerous interviews with West Texas residents, including grocery store owners and librarians, reveal a different narrative. Many were either oblivious to the ongoing controversy or chose not to comment. Residents from Marfa, Alpine, and Fort Stockton indicated a lack of additional insights when approached.
“You have to consider the timing,” Falcon remarked, acknowledging the gravity of the situation surrounding the alleged affair.
Gonzales’s campaign has not responded to requests for interviews regarding the current challenges he faces.
The upcoming primary election is a crucial moment for Gonzales, who is set to compete against rising right-wing figure Brandon Herrera. The primary, taking place on Tuesday, marks a rematch; Gonzales narrowly edged out Herrera in the 2024 primary runoff by a mere few hundred votes.
Resentment toward Gonzales has simmered in the staunchly Republican areas of West Texas for years. Even among those who have supported him in the past, skepticism about his ability to win the March 3 primary is palpable.
The Navy veteran and former cryptologist secured his seat in 2020 by defeating Raul Reyes, succeeding retiring U.S. Rep. Will Hurd, who had alienated conservatives for his opposition to President Donald Trump’s border wall. Initially, local political figures viewed Gonzales as a fresh opportunity to promote conservative values.
Yet, even before the recent scandal, Gonzales struggled to build voter trust, according to Tammie Smith, chair of the Upton County Republican Party. “He didn’t engage well with people,” she remarked. However, securing a conservative representative was crucial for rural Republicans, many of whom saw Gonzales as a potential advocate for their values, even if Smith herself was not entirely convinced.
Smith expressed disappointment, noting that Gonzales ceased regular communication with her shortly after taking office, even neglecting to inform her about visits to her community. Furthermore, his voting record has raised eyebrows, especially after he supported the Bipartisan Safer Communities Act following the tragic Uvalde mass shooting, becoming the only Texas Republican to do so. His backing of the federal recognition of same-sex marriages further alienated him from the conservative base.
“He voted for red flag laws, he voted for same-sex marriages, and those aren’t our values,” Smith asserted. “When we elect someone, we expect them to represent our beliefs, and we’re not seeing that.”
Smith’s husband, Finis, emphasized the disconnect between urban and rural voters. “How can you even represent all of CD-23 when you’re stuck inside the larger cities?” he questioned.
The Smiths believe Gonzales should resign, suggesting that the scandal gives Herrera an advantage, despite some discomfort with Herrera’s approach.
Democrats, though few in West Texas, previously viewed Gonzales as a Republican open to collaboration. Now, concerns arise about how a more extreme candidate might approach local issues. Recently, residents in the Big Bend area were taken aback to learn about federal plans to extend the border wall along the ecologically significant Big Bend National Park, igniting anger among long-standing local families.
“Tony Gonzales might have been helpful in fighting that border wall,” noted Susan Hays, a Marfa Democrat running for the Presidio County Commissioners Court. She believes Gonzales could have sided with local opposers to prevent construction in the national park.
“Now I don’t even think he’s going to win his primary,” she concluded.
Falcon, who currently serves on the Fort Stockton city council, echoed Hays’s sentiments. He praised Gonzales for his problem-solving skills and ability to meet the diverse needs of various districts.
“He helped secure nearly half a million dollars for the Fort Stockton Police Department and directed $1 million in grants to a local health clinic,” Falcon recounted. “He understood the importance of supporting smaller communities, which is no easy task.”
However, Falcon acknowledged that the scandal could significantly jeopardize Gonzales’s chances for reelection. He expressed concern about the potential need for a new congressperson to relearn the intricacies of the job.
David Beebe, a self-described conservative Democrat and former Presidio County Commissioner, reflected on Gonzales’s performance in Congress but is considerably less optimistic about his electoral prospects. Gonzales had previously provided substantial financial assistance to Presidio, sending $1.7 million to the county’s health department, and was known for his willingness to collaborate with Democrats on contentious issues.
Yet, Beebe believes the recent scandal will overshadow Gonzales’s past accomplishments, particularly in Presidio, a county that still supports Democratic candidates.
“This is a traditional place where people value integrity and community,” Beebe remarked. “When you’re in a position of power, such actions don’t sit well. I think Tony is in serious trouble.”
A campaign sign for Brandon Herrera stands prominently in McCamey, a town situated about 55 miles south of Odessa.
